What are you drinking tonight 2022?

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
The temp started at 14c for first 24 hours and then up to 15c. It stayed at this level until it was 85-90% done then ramped up to 20c over the final days. It was at the lower end of the Kolsch/common yeast
Might give wyeast German ale a go next time see if that makes a positive difference. Never brewed a sour beer before, and I have a separate all-rounder that I use for any diasaticus or non clean yeast strains .
I used the dry version as the specs suggested it was high flocculation and seemed to have a higher attenuation spec compared to German ale but maybe the liquid German ale might give it a smoother fermentation
Then the only other thing is infection!
https://winning-homebrew.com/sour-flavors-in-beer.htmlThat second score sheet I would email him and ask him to print out what he thought, he writes like an out of work doctor. You have a right to a legible explanation.
 
Then the only other thing is infection!
https://winning-homebrew.com/sour-flavors-in-beer.htmlThat second score sheet I would email him and ask him to print out what he thought, he writes like an out of work doctor. You have a right to a legible explanation.
Yes that second score sheet gave me a headache trying to read it...
I'm actually thinking that one of the judges commented on something acidic or astringent and then went on the hunt for it. A few people that I trust to call out issues, another beer judge and the owner of the brewery that runs our homebrew club have all said it was clean and malty.
I have been thinking about changing the UK crisp Munich malt to a Weyermann Munich 1 . When I brewed it the first time I used alot more Munich and aromatic malt(followed Jamils classic styles) and I thought it seemed too malty/fruity so I cut the aromatic which has improved it but compared to the commercial versions I have had they seemed slightly less malty. Thinking the German produced Munich might give a slightly different profile, what do you think?
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20220608-081844.jpg
    Screenshot_20220608-081844.jpg
    46.4 KB
Yes that second score sheet gave me a headache trying to read it...
I'm actually thinking that one of the judges commented on something acidic or astringent and then went on the hunt for it. A few people that I trust to call out issues, another beer judge and the owner of the brewery that runs our homebrew club have all said it was clean and malty.
I have been thinking about changing the UK crisp Munich malt to a Weyermann Munich 1 . When I brewed it the first time I used alot more Munich and aromatic malt(followed Jamils classic styles) and I thought it seemed too malty/fruity so I cut the aromatic which has improved it but compared to the commercial versions I have had they seemed slightly less malty. Thinking the German produced Munich might give a slightly different profile, what do you think?
I love dingemans aromatic, it is very similar to honey malt to me and it does leave more of a sweeter tart/fruity flavour when I taste it.

I wonder if you would be better off with melanoiden malt which does not have that sweetness thing going but is more rich malty?
 
I love dingemans aromatic, it is very similar to honey malt to me and it does leave more of a sweeter tart/fruity flavour when I taste it.

I wonder if you would be better off with melanoiden malt which does not have that sweetness thing going but is more rich malty?
Interesting...think I over used that once in a Czech Amber..came across a little raisin 🤔
 
Last edited:
I love dingemans aromatic, it is very similar to honey malt to me and it does leave more of a sweeter tart/fruity flavour when I taste it.

I wonder if you would be better off with melanoiden malt which does not have that sweetness thing going but is more rich malty?
What you think..my notes said a little malt fruity. What do you think caused it from these grains. This was a Czech amber
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20220608-171309.jpg
    Screenshot_20220608-171309.jpg
    51.9 KB
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top