where's all the AG brewers gone

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
...and at the risk of whacking the wasp-bike (byke?) I think sometimes fora such as this suffer a little bit as they and the associated hobby mature and become more accessible to the mainstream.

I found and joined a great SCUBA newsgroup, uk.rec.scuba, many moons ago as a "not even certified but done a few and really keen" newbie diver and was able to lurk for a bit, learn, join in after a bit, and progress. They bemoaned the fall off of divers at the top end, forgetting where they started, how they progressed in diving and and the part in that progression that UKRS played. They wondered why numbers on the trips were falling, they wondered why there were fewer trips being run.

In truth, they progressed their skills to the point of exclusion of the new members. There were precious few divers joining and being coached and included and brought up through to that top level and so it all kind of peetered out. A great shame, I met some great people and made a few friends and had some awesome adventures.

It would be truly horrible for that to happen here. I mixed my first Young's Bitter kit six and a half months ago and since then have brewed 55 gallons of beer, nearly if not all of which has been better than anything I could buy for an equivalent price. Some (notably the treacle stout, admirals reserve and better brew pils) are just quite simply better than most equivalents you can buy in the shops. Would I have had that level of success without you lot? No.

Why did I start brewing? Money. I can't drink supermarket swill, it is rank. I like proper beer and I like a good supply of it. I'm trying to keep SWMBO off work to look after the offspring so pennies are being counted. But I'm not going to compromise or, heavens forbid, stop drinking.

Now that I know that I can, even including the cost of the equipment bought so far, produce awesome beer, out of a couple of cans, for less than a quid a pint that is economically awesome.

What you lot have done is to make me realise how easy it is to not just follow the instructions, to go off piste, to brew other stuff (thanks GA for all the great TC advice, I'm getting VERY impatient mind...), to mod the kits to get something different etc etc.

What you have also done is demystify AG. The "how to" sections, the good grace with which the newbie AG questions are answered, the explanations and discussions of the science and the practise behind the answers, the cost saving tips and tricks, and myriad other useful snipets have lowered the bar massively for me and, as soon as I have the space to do it I'll be buying some pots, a gas burner and some grain.

Maybe one day I'll be able to give my experience of more than a just a bit pf process analysis on mixing up kits in tiny spaces... Maybe one day I'll be able to inspire like the old hands here do... Maybe one day I'll be responsible for pulling a couple of interested noobs through from the first taste of their first kit, through kits mods, first AG from a recipe, first own recipe and so on...

But that's just it, everyone has their reason to start, mine was "cheap beer that is palletable". You'll always get those who try it and get bored, you'll always get those who are after just making some kind of hooch on the cheap, but the important thing is to always remember that they, and the people who end up with the nano-breweries producing cracking beer will, on the whole, both start from humble beginnings. With six months' experience and successes my motivation now is "awesome beer that's also quite cheap and the buzz of making it myself".

THBF has been so inclusive while I've been here, one of the friendliest places I hang around on the 'net. Maybe some feel that the balance of AG to BIAB to Extract to Kit to cheap hooch brewers is out of kilter a bit but if that's the case then the only way to change it and preserve this awesome resource is to stay totally inclusive, to educate, inspire and push (gently, just a little bit) those with less experience up the ladder rung by rung with the good grace and patience you constantly show.

It wouldn't be right for THBF to go the way of UKRS, where the "elite" kind of drop off the top leaving no glue to keep the thing together, no one to inspire the noobs coming through to take up the reins.

So there. :cheers:
 
graysalchemy said:
Perhaps more of us should write more how-to's?

Yup, and more Brew FAQ's?

Happy to chip in, of course, so long as you old-hands will peer-review, given my lack of experience...
 
I don't think it would. The forum is a place to discuss. The how tos and faqs are places to get that basic info, the forum the place to discuss how you would want to implement it, how you might do it differently to suit your particular circumstance - or indeed ask for the advice when that howto or faq won't quite fit your space/circumstance/style/whatever.

Brewing seems to occupy a peculiar niche - there are some basic techniques that form the building blocks of an infitely complex hobby when you introduce equipment, ingredients, styles and personal taste. That's what drives the conversation and the hobby forward I think...

...having the basics and some complex topics documented well from our collective musings (as we do, in part with the faqs and howtos) shouldn't detract from that at all, it could even enhance it?
 
http://cheeseforum.org has a very good wiki which doesn't detract from the forum. I want to take up cheese making and I often refer to the wiki to get my head round it as I did with brewing, I may even join and start lurking around.

I sometimes feel that I should write a how to on my take on TC as I invariably write the same thing once a week. I did get slated for this the other week but if I don't write about it people won't get to learn and invariably give up making TC because it tastes cr*p.
 
Good Ed said:
I think a lot of the kind of posts "my airlock is not bubbling Heeeeeeeeeelp" could be avoided if people were able to help themselves more.

Hmmmm, would this have been my thread :p

I love this place. It's very difficult nowadays to actually find a forum where the members are so actively involved as everyone is here.

I started with kits purely because I was given one of the Youngs Larger U Brew kits for Christmas. I will definitely be going AG in the future, but before I do though I want to make sure I understand the process, and what happens at each stage and kits give me the opportunity to do that without messing it up so easily.

I hope I haven't questioned anyones knowledge (my memory isn't the best now I'm getting old, 29) in my quest to become a master brewer. If I have though I am very sorry. I would much rather learn from people who do it regularly than from a book. You find the answers you want a lot quicker.
 
graysalchemy said:
I sometimes feel that I should write a how to on my take on TC as I invariably write the same thing once a week. I did get slated for this the other week but if I don't write about it people won't get to learn and invariably give up making TC because it tastes cr*p.

I think you should. You really are the font of quality TC knowledge, and a how-to-cum-science-of peice on TC would be a great addition I feel. Then *everyone* can push the Grays TC agenda by pointing all the TC noobs to your How To!! :D
 
crofty83 said:
Good Ed said:
I think a lot of the kind of posts "my airlock is not bubbling Heeeeeeeeeelp" could be avoided if people were able to help themselves more.

Hmmmm, would this have been my thread :p

I love this place. It's very difficult nowadays to actually find a forum where the members are so actively involved as everyone is here.

Agreed!

crofty83 said:
I started with kits purely because I was given one of the Youngs Larger U Brew kits for Christmas. I will definitely be going AG in the future, but before I do though I want to make sure I understand the process, and what happens at each stage and kits give me the opportunity to do that without messing it up so easily.

*ahem* ;)

crofty83 said:
I hope I haven't questioned anyones knowledge (my memory isn't the best now I'm getting old, 29) in my quest to become a master brewer. If I have though I am very sorry. I would much rather learn from people who do it regularly than from a book. You find the answers you want a lot quicker.

Books are great but they give you the author's take on a subject and that's all. Here you get the sum of the experience of dozens and dozens of experienced brewers. You don't just get a question answered here - you get lots of answers and a healthy dollop of guidance too. "So what? You could get dozens of books." But who's going to guide you to the solution which is best for you...

...not just quicker - better! :D
 
One of the intentions with the new CBA forum will be to collate debated answers into a wiki, and once the wiki is in place and 'stable' then to publish that as a book. The issues we have are that we have a somewhat restricted membership, with very few people posting, so it is going to take some time.

However, it is also difficult to do the same here and on JBK mainly due to the amount of 'noise' that really detracts from teh brewing information. Don't get me wrong I don't want either forum to change as it is the 'noise' that makes the forums such a great place to be, unfortunately it makes it difficult to find information.
 
The CBA would sound like a better place for a Wiki

And a book :hmm: :hmm:

Not the long awaited book is it Aleman :lol: :lol:
 
crofty83 said:
Good Ed said:
I think a lot of the kind of posts "my airlock is not bubbling Heeeeeeeeeelp" could be avoided if people were able to help themselves more.

Hmmmm, would this have been my thread :p

I love this place. It's very difficult nowadays to actually find a forum where the members are so actively involved as everyone is here.

I started with kits purely because I was given one of the Youngs Larger U Brew kits for Christmas. I will definitely be going AG in the future, but before I do though I want to make sure I understand the process, and what happens at each stage and kits give me the opportunity to do that without messing it up so easily.

I hope I haven't questioned anyones knowledge (my memory isn't the best now I'm getting old, 29) in my quest to become a master brewer. If I have though I am very sorry. I would much rather learn from people who do it regularly than from a book. You find the answers you want a lot quicker.


Um Crofty I didn't mean this to be personal to you, all I was trying to say was that if people did a bit of research themselves, and there is no excuse for not doing that in this day and age, a lot posts regarding simple questions could be eliminated. But by all means if anyone is not sure of anything ask away, just try and do your own research to answer your own question first.

If you are new to brewing you need to understand the principles, so you know what's going on, it's the same with anything in life. It's the same old chestnut, you get out of something what you put in.
 
I would much rather learn from people who do it regularly than from a book. You find the answers you want a lot quicker.

Reading a book for information is great, i do it on every hoby i take up before actually acting.
The issue with a book is that 10 people can read the same paragraph and interpret it 10 different ways.

With the forum you will get those 10 different interpretations which makes it easier allows you to then make your own informed decition and your own way forward.

As for the question my "airlock is not bubbling Heeeeeeeeeelp" i assume that was the title and not the actual question, maybe just to grab someones attention?

The original poster maybe had already looked everywhere else and not found the answer to his/her problem so asked here, We see it posted all the time "the only stupid question is one not asked"

I sometimes ask what some would deem to be a stupid or even lazy question to indicate i have not bothered to search for the answer for myself, but 9 time out of 10 i have searched and found plenty of options but then by asking a simple question been given far better information or even a link to somthing that i myself didn't find for what ever reason!

I am new to brewing and as such brew with kits only at the moment, i would love to move onto AG but at pressent don't have the time, knowledge or the space to do it.

When we move to our next house, 2 to 5 years from now i will have a garage and will deffinately be seeting up my own nanno brewery but at this time i get a great pint from the 2 can kits that im useing.

I can honestly say though that i have had every question i have asked on this forum answered in a friendly and very helpfull manner, so for that i thank everyone on here :clap: :cheers:

Andy
 
Or could it possibly have been a meaningless reply that added nothing to the thread :whistle: :whistle: :whistle:
 
I have found the forum to be very agreeable, friendly even, I have asked loads of questions & probably not used the search as much as I should have but my 1st brew is now in the keg and I am already thinking about turning to the darkside, I only found this forum when I was looking for a way to brew something similar to Hobgoblin at home, I think I will need to go all grain to achieve this so it wont be too long till I turn, finances are the only thing stopping me at this stage & I have not even had a pint of my first brew yet!
 
BrotherMalice said:
finances are the only thing stopping me at this stage
Yes, it is quite a consideration!
Plastic is obviously the cheaper way, but then comes along the desire for "Shiney"
So the reasonable argument is why pay out twice, why not wait until "Shiney" is affordable?
A very good point, but oh how the AG beckons!
A true "horns of a dilemma"!

Me, the original skinflint, never progressed beyond plastic. :oops:
 
Plastic I think will be the way for the mashtun (2 FV's 1 inside the other with holes drilled) want to get a big metal pot to do the boiling bit though, is this possible on a cooker in the kitchen? - I have a fairly tollerant SWMBO (some days anyway...)
 
Back
Top