Electric cars.

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

The EV-charging blackspots fuelling 'range fear'​

1739719414285.png


The sale of new diesel and petrol cars is set to be phased out in the UK over the next decade – but figures show Yorkshire is falling behind in the race to provide sufficient public electric vehicle (EV) charging points.
Bradford was recently given £3m in government funding to boost infrastructure, but some in the district fear demand will outstrip supply, deterring drivers from making the EV switch.
For Tony Maw, transitioning to EV is both inevitable and welcome.
However, he remains hesitant to trade in his hybrid for a fully electric car, citing so-called "range fear" as a key concern.
He asks: "Where can you charge your car in rural communities?

"People cannot necessarily even park by their house, they have to park up against a wall somewhere."
There isn't a single on-street rapid EV charger in his village of Oxenhope, near Keighley, he says.
"When I was going hybrid, I needed a charging point at home because you don't get a great deal of mileage on electric with a hybrid.
"Some people have the opportunity to do that, but those in other places can't."

The government aims to install 300,000 chargers in the UK by 2030, but fewer than 100,000 are currently in operation.
"The number of chargers needed is probably going to exceed the current plans," he adds.
Rebecca Poulsen, a councillor for the Worth Valley area which includes Oxenhope, says there is an urgent need for local authorities to "look at the gaps in charging".
"Commercial operators install big charging schemes in urban areas, but in smaller villages even one or two chargers could make the difference in whether people decide to get an electric car or not," she says.
"New technology is coming, on-street charging on street lights or under pavements for example, but we need to ramp up efforts."
The Labour-run Bradford Council has secured central funding to install 1,000 new chargers at more than 200 underserved locations, with the areas yet to be confirmed.
Poulsen, Conservative group leader on the local authority, adds: "If a village has just one charger and it's broken, how far is it to another?
"People need confidence that they can charge their vehicles."

Department for Transport figures show 73,334 public chargers have been installed nationwide so far as of 1 January 2025, with 19,657 built during 2024.
But the data, external also shows that Yorkshire and the Humber is the worst served UK mainland region per 100,000 of the population, alongside the North West.
Both regions have just 66 EV points per 100,000 of the population.
The government has launched initiatives to accelerate the UK rollout, including £450m of Local Electric Vehicle Infrastructure (LEVI) funding.
However the scrapping of road tax exemptions for EV is set to be pushed through from April, with tension between manufacturers and ministers in recent months over targets.
Differences in cost between public and at-home charging has also been a major factor.

Philip Douglass, who is leading a Vauxhall campaign to improve access to EV charging for those who don't have a driveway, says: "We found that 40% of UK households don't have a driveway, but 80% of charging happens at home."
The driveway figure rose to 60% in places like Bradford, with the district's terraced streets and remote villages proving a challenge.
"Only 25,000 of the 75,000 [UK] public chargers are in residential areas, which is where we need them most," Mr Douglass adds.
The campaign wants everyone to be living within a four-minute walk of an on-street charger as soon as possible.

Some private sector interventions are making a quiet impact, with a new super-fast charging hub on a hotel site off the M606 in Bradford featuring 16 units in total, and another rapid hub nearby operating out of a drive-through bakery shop car park.
Yasir Hafeez, who bought his EV six weeks ago through a work salary sacrifice scheme, currently makes a 20-mile round trip from Halifax to charge in Bradford.
"I used to have a diesel, which was very expensive - £300 a month just on fuel, plus road tax and insurance," he says.
"This one is much cheaper."
He agrees about the lack of on-street charger coverage, adding: "I have to come here to charge my car.
"There's no supercharger near me."

Wayne Topley, managing director of the Cedar Court Hotel, says hosting the super-fast charging station is a decision to help "futureproof" the business.
"Being an EV owner myself, I do have range anxiety and I have to plan ahead for charging on long journeys," he says.
"I don't think it will be long before we start seeing trucks on the road with large battery capacity, and having central locations like this will really help build confidence for longer journeys."
While the increase in larger, rapid charge locations near key roads is helping in the EV push, many feel its overall success begins at home.
Mr Douglass concludes: "If we don't get electric vehicle infrastructure in that near-home space, we risk creating a two-tier vehicle market where some people can get the latest technology and some people can't."
Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North or Politics North, or tell us a story you think we should be covering by emailing [email protected].
 
been reading up on this and Harry Matcalfes channel he is very clued up in the motor scene aside from his political views a lot of sense spoken. Harry's Garage

A large number of manufactures are moving back to ICE production as still strong markets in other countries.

Europe seems to be moving to Hybrids with decent range and it seems this is what customer want as well.

There is a real danger the UK could be a outsider forcing the EV only mandate, given we are niche market being RHD, there may be a point where its just not worthwhile to plough big money into research and development of RHD BEV when there is not the demand.

We could end up with costs shooting up with scale of economies hitting hard as the manufacturers focus on hybrids that would be outlawed in the UK.

This is not as crazy as you think Tesla knew the Cybertruck was not complaint with UK safety regulations but made it clear they will not look at any changes and if the UK doesn't want it then fine.

The impact on industry is already showing.

The UK Government needs to wake up to this personally I would support the French model shown in Harry's video, by all means come down hard on high polluting ICE and I like the tie in to vehicle weight, but crucially they do not hammer Hybrids or BEV. I think a more realistic target should be set - by all means keep the full ICE ban but allow hybrids with low emissions ICE but set a minimum electric only range say 50 miles to start with but rising to 75 miles by year 5 and 100 miles by year 10 and so on. If this was agreed across Europe or wider then it could drive the development of batteries and charging networks but still meet customer demands and allow a soft transition to full EV if you have a hybrid with 200 mile battery range I would bet most would stop using petrol or diesel and if the smart systems like Toyota have can extend the range of ICE the use of fossil fuel is further reduced.

The time scales for full BEV are not realistic given the infrastructure and crazy tax system
 
Well obviously a guy who used to work for evo magazine is mostly interested in what Lotus and Porsche are doing - but they're barely a rounding error in the global scheme of things. As he says later, the small car segment - the stuff that people drive in the real world - is going over to EVs, mostly made by the Chinese. But eg he talks a lot about VW but doesn't mention their €25k "Polo"-equivalent EV coming next year, or the €20k "Up!"-equivalent EV the year after.

If you look at EV sales in 2024 :

90% Norway
54% China
20% UK
15% EU
8% US

So obviously, if your main market is China or Norway then you want to do EVs, if you're wanting to sell to the US then a policy of all-electric by 2030 doesn't make much sense, as it appears that the regime there until 2029 won't be doing much to change that 8% figure. That's all that Lotus and Volvo are responding to.

Norway shows it can be done already, the technology is there and it works in a big, cold country - but it helps to be a country that's profiting massively from selling fossil fuels to the ROTW.

As for the Cybertruck - it's looking like an irrelevance. They've already announced that they're not going to use stainless steel for any other cars, it looks like Musk wanted Tesla shareholders to pay for fabrication research for SpaceX. If Tesla had just done a "normal" pickup they could have had a winner on their hands, instead they've got inventory piling up of Musk's folly. They adapted it to sell in Canada because the 2024 model is not eligible for US subsidies whilst the 2025 model is, but they're never going to sell it in Europe due to EU rules on pedestrian safety and it's just a daft vehicle for European roads.

https://electrek.co/2025/02/14/tesla-offers-up-to-6000-cybertruck-discounts-as-inventory-pile-up/
 
Last edited:
Well obviously a guy who used to work for evo magazine is mostly interested in what Lotus and Porsche are doing - but they're barely a rounding error in the global scheme of things. As he says later, the small car segment - the stuff that people drive in the real world - is going over to EVs, mostly made by the Chinese. But eg he talks a lot about VW but doesn't mention their €25k "Polo"-equivalent EV coming next year, or the €20k "Up!"-equivalent EV the year after.

If you look at EV sales in 2024 :

90% Norway
54% China
20% UK
15% EU
8% US

So obviously, if your main market is China or Norway then you want to do EVs, if you're wanting to sell to the US then a policy of all-electric by 2030 doesn't make much sense, as it appears that the regime there until 2029 won't be doing much to change that 8% figure. That's all that Lotus and Volvo are responding to.

Norway shows it can be done already, the technology is there and it works in a big, cold country - but it helps to be a country that's profiting massively from selling fossil fuels to the ROTW.

As for the Cybertruck - it's looking like an irrelevance. They've already announced that they're not going to use stainless steel for any other cars, it looks like Musk wanted Tesla shareholders to pay for fabrication research for SpaceX. If Tesla had just done a "normal" pickup they could have had a winner on their hands, instead they've got inventory piling up of Musk's folly. They adapted it to sell in Canada because the 2024 model is not eligible for US subsidies whilst the 2025 model is, but they're never going to sell it in Europe due to EU rules on pedestrian safety and it's just a daft vehicle for European roads.

https://electrek.co/2025/02/14/tesla-offers-up-to-6000-cybertruck-discounts-as-inventory-pile-up/
I very much doubt the Cyber Truck will meet pedestrian standards anywhere else in the world basic flaw is total lack of crumple zones due the load bearing external frame, this means the sharp edges cant be rounded off without reducing the structural design - UK and Euro regs state no sharp edges. the light full width and combined lights also do not meet UK or Euro safety spec.

The Cyber Truck aside the point Harry's video is making (btw yes he was once editor of EVO but has been a motoring journalist for a VERY long time and well respected by most) is that customer demand is not matching current UK policy, car makers can not sell as many BEVs as the policy demands and this is getting tougher year on year, the refusal to soften to allow Hybrids is out of step with the rest of the world.
For balance I have a BEV its not perfect far from it but I fortunate enough to have a home charger, if I did have not, in my area it would not be viable financially or geographically.
The infrastructure is not there at present, my other half wants to go away next weekend I have judge where i can get a fast charge as leaving my BEV to charge for & hours on a 7KW charger is not viable when you do not have another vehicle or the only driver in the household. I thought no problem lets look for a 50 KW charger near where we are staying nope nearest 40 miles away and no 7kw within 10 miles, a good hybrid i would not has had to worry about this.
 
That's interesting.

Do you mean in the population at large, or kw per mile in an EV?
https://www.statista.com/statistics...-electricity-suppliers-in-the-united-kingdom/

Total electricity consumption in the UK has been falling since 2005 - I don't know the proposed reasons but I'm guessing efficient appliances and LED bulbs primarily. Anyway the point being that EVs aren't outstripping capacity. Scotland massively produces more than it uses - exports about 16TWh, https://www.gov.scot/publications/energy-statistics-for-scotland-q4-2023/pages/electricity-exports/

I live half my time in Orkney now, and the wind turbines still have to regularly be shut off as the cable connection to the mainland can't cope with the full generation capacity - it is being sorted but it is annoying we don't get to have the spare stuff for free!
 
I live half my time in Orkney now, and the wind turbines still have to regularly be shut off as the cable connection to the mainland can't cope with the full generation capacity - it is being sorted but it is annoying we don't get to have the spare stuff for free!

To some extent that happens everywhere, it is load balancing. I think it's a real shame we have not mastered storage technology.
 
Except that article doesn't try to explain why that particular kind of brake would be used more by EVs than ICE, and it minimises the fact that regenerative braking standard on just about every EV on sale in the UK as it really helps to improve range - and really cuts down on brake use. Saying that "some EVs have regenerative braking" gives a misleading impression of reality.

The original researchers put a rather different spin on things, they're just saying "we've removed the big source of emissions/pollution, now we have to think about sources that we didn't even worry about before"

https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2025/02/brake-pad-emissions.page
 
The Cyber Truck aside the point Harry's video is making (btw yes he was once editor of EVO but has been a motoring journalist for a VERY long time and well respected by most)
Nonetheless, he puts disproportionate weight on "sexy" brands that are a tiny part of the market.
is that customer demand is not matching current UK policy, car makers can not sell as many BEVs as the policy demands
That's simply not true - the industry hit the targets in 2024, not that you would guess from the SMMT or the media. Yes the targets were the equivalent of 22% EVs and they only sold 19.6% EVs - but you can also get points towards the targets by reducing CO2 emissions from the rest of their range (ie hybrids and efficient ICE), which took them over the 22%. Given that EV market share was up 50% year-on-year last month, the industry are in good shape to hit this year's target of 28% equivalent. Porsche and Lotus are irrelevant in this context - what matters is what the likes of VW, Hyundai, Ford and Nissan are doing.

Two of which are on top of it, as they can see the way the mass market is going, and they're not complaining about the policy, far from it. But Detroit and Japan have badly misread the way things are going in Europe and have completely screwed up on their model plans. Of course Ford are vociferous against an EV mandate - because they only have the e-Mustang in their range, and now the "Capri"-that's-nothing-like-a-Capri. So of course they're struggling - and the market is voting with its feet, Ford are down 32% yoy in the UK. Where's the electric Mondeo/Focus/Kuga/Fiesta?

Compare that with VW's range, where I remember seeing an e-Golf at the 2012 Olympic marathons, and they're going to complete their range with an electric "Polo", "T-Cross" and "Up!" within the next two years. Might be no coincidence that VW are up 18% yoy in the UK.

I also saw recently that over half of new Minis are now electric.

For balance I have a BEV its not perfect far from it but I fortunate enough to have a home charger, if I did have not, in my area it would not be viable financially or geographically.
The infrastructure is not there at present, my other half wants to go away next weekend I have judge where i can get a fast charge as leaving my BEV to charge for & hours on a 7KW charger is not viable when you do not have another vehicle or the only driver in the household. I thought no problem lets look for a 50 KW charger near where we are staying nope nearest 40 miles away and no 7kw within 10 miles, a good hybrid i would not has had to worry about this.
I'm sorry, this just needs planning - because you know what, the kind of places that are so remote that they don't have fast chargers, don't have petrol stations either.

I've spent a lot of time in a petrol car with a range of ~260 miles (big thirsty engine, small tank) in remote bits of the Highlands where the nearest petrol station is ~40 minutes round trip away. And you know what, I managed - I just filled up before leaving the A9, and would get back to the A9 on fumes. I used to joke about how an electric car would be a much better option in such a remote place because it would allow me to "fill up" overnight without having to make that 40 minute round trip.

Do you not have a "granny charger"? If you're in a cottage you can just hook up to the mains, and most hotels in the Highlands have some kind of arrangement for filling up electric cars, without it being registered on an app as an official charger.

And there will only be more chargers, we already have more chargers in the UK than petrol pumps, and 19,834 charge points were added in 2024, of which about 20% were >50kW. It's not perfect, but we're getting there.
 

I don’t think anyone is claiming that EVs are 100% green. Even if you could make a car out of hemp and run it on tomatoes you’d still have emissions making the fertiliser to grow them. Doesn’t mean that it’s not a better alternative to the status quo.

As for the article, any car with regenerative braking is going to use the brake pads a lot less than a pure ICE car, so I hope everyone can agree an EV or hybrid is going to be better than pure ICE.

There might be a case for a diesel hybrid vs EV, but I’m struggling to believe it.
 
I don’t think anyone is claiming that EVs are 100% green. Even if you could make a car out of hemp and run it on tomatoes you’d still have emissions making the fertiliser to grow them. Doesn’t mean that it’s not a better alternative to the status quo.

As for the article, any car with regenerative braking is going to use the brake pads a lot less than a pure ICE car, so I hope everyone can agree an EV or hybrid is going to be better than pure ICE.

There might be a case for a diesel hybrid vs EV, but I’m struggling to believe it.
I agree with you but it is looking more like the green dream of Milliband is not going to happen all he is doing is driving the price of electricity up
 
As a side note, I see car prices/sales are going to get another disruption with the car loan legal case starting next month.

And I'm sure the post COVID 2nd hand ex fleet sales numbers are enough to make used car prices more reasonable for those with modest employment.
 
Ok i take your point having read your link, looks like we are chasing the rabbit down the hole
Just as a comment - the standard of reporting on anything to do with science in the general media is terrible, and I have learnt to always go to the original source where possible. On the internet everything is a few clicks away - even if they don't provide a link as here, it's easy enough to Google the lead scientist's name and there is usually a press release from their university which explains things much better.

That's particularly true when it comes to EVs and heat pumps where there's a lot of propaganda and straight-out lies published by the mainstream media.
I agree with you but it is looking more like the green dream of Milliband is not going to happen all he is doing is driving the price of electricity up
Again - beware the propaganda of some people in the media. In the last year wholesale electricity prices have been between £75-85/MWh, which is the lowest they have been for a couple of years. The UK is almost unique in the way that it is so dependent on gas for setting the price of electricity, and importing a lot of gas means our electricity price depends on the world gas price, which in turn depends on places like Russia and the Middle East staying sane.

Historically that's not a great bet. So doesn't it make sense to try and generate as much electricity domestically, even if that means generating from wind a lot of the time and then just using domestic gas for when the wind doesn't blow? Because business as usual isn't an option - either we generate more domestically or we allow ourselves to become more dependent on importing gas from places like Qatar.

1739879820495.png
 

He doesn't mention that you hardly use the brakes in a BEV due to regenerative braking which as we all know is an energy recovery mechanism that slows down a moving vehicle or object by converting its kinetic energy or potential energy into a form that can be either used immediately or stored until needed.

Edit to add -
I missed Northerns post above about regenerative braking.

From Rods article above - “As we shift from diesel and petrol-powered cars to electric cars, emissions of non-exhaust particulate matter will not disappear,” he stated, as cited by Boosted. “In fact, they could increase because electric vehicles are heavier, putting more strain on brakes, tires, and roads.”
The study found that brake dust, especially from certain types of brake pads, is highly toxic. Non-asbestos brake pads with high copper content were even more harmful to lung cells than diesel exhaust particles.
 
On the subject of public chargers we now have 14 in our small town one free charger in the church car park, three pay and display car parks have two chargers in each and Booths supermarket now has seven.


1739887759843.png
1739888089779.png
 
Last edited:
agree utter tosh about brake dust look at the high mileage MG5's still on their original pads they only get used in my car below 5 mph or extreme braking all other braking is regen and by using auto regen it reads the road and applies regen before I brake the Kia/Hyundia system is very good at this.

As for burning up tyres again not true of every BEV the heavy high powered ones yes maybe but that same for ICE like this, now we have moderate powered EVs and better mapping they are not ripping up tyres.
As for weight my 5 year old Kona is no heavier than the diesel fords I had before it.
The level of myths about EVs is staggering
 
Nonetheless, he puts disproportionate weight on "sexy" brands that are a tiny part of the market.

That's simply not true - the industry hit the targets in 2024, not that you would guess from the SMMT or the media. Yes the targets were the equivalent of 22% EVs and they only sold 19.6% EVs - but you can also get points towards the targets by reducing CO2 emissions from the rest of their range (ie hybrids and efficient ICE), which took them over the 22%. Given that EV market share was up 50% year-on-year last month, the industry are in good shape to hit this year's target of 28% equivalent. Porsche and Lotus are irrelevant in this context - what matters is what the likes of VW, Hyundai, Ford and Nissan are doing.

Two of which are on top of it, as they can see the way the mass market is going, and they're not complaining about the policy, far from it. But Detroit and Japan have badly misread the way things are going in Europe and have completely screwed up on their model plans. Of course Ford are vociferous against an EV mandate - because they only have the e-Mustang in their range, and now the "Capri"-that's-nothing-like-a-Capri. So of course they're struggling - and the market is voting with its feet, Ford are down 32% yoy in the UK. Where's the electric Mondeo/Focus/Kuga/Fiesta?

Compare that with VW's range, where I remember seeing an e-Golf at the 2012 Olympic marathons, and they're going to complete their range with an electric "Polo", "T-Cross" and "Up!" within the next two years. Might be no coincidence that VW are up 18% yoy in the UK.

I also saw recently that over half of new Minis are now electric.


I'm sorry, this just needs planning - because you know what, the kind of places that are so remote that they don't have fast chargers, don't have petrol stations either.

I've spent a lot of time in a petrol car with a range of ~260 miles (big thirsty engine, small tank) in remote bits of the Highlands where the nearest petrol station is ~40 minutes round trip away. And you know what, I managed - I just filled up before leaving the A9, and would get back to the A9 on fumes. I used to joke about how an electric car would be a much better option in such a remote place because it would allow me to "fill up" overnight without having to make that 40 minute round trip.

Do you not have a "granny charger"? If you're in a cottage you can just hook up to the mains, and most hotels in the Highlands have some kind of arrangement for filling up electric cars, without it being registered on an app as an official charger.

And there will only be more chargers, we already have more chargers in the UK than petrol pumps, and 19,834 charge points were added in 2024, of which about 20% were >50kW. It's not perfect, but we're getting there.
I passed several petrol stations, but even if i did not my old focus could cover over 600 miles on a tank so never worried about it.

Ironically last place we went had a 7kw charger but was turned off had been for 14 months. That would have been perfect left overnight back up to 200 miles easy.

Good point I had the granny charger but the Kona had enough range to get back just, so in future might need to try that at lodges not as easy at hotels.

Some parts of the country are well served for charging but massive holes when you look at some areas of Scotland. 7kw chargers are so slow its not practical to sit in the car that length or if lucky enough to have a cafe or someplace near by an hour or 2 maybe, but last 2 trips this not been possible. There is a real lack of fast, for me 50kw is more than enough 40 mins gets me to 80% my car only goes to 77kw anyways so no gain for me gong higher) in more remote areas, ironically in cities and built up areas there are loads.

As for VW the Buzz has been a massive sales flop and the ID 7 got withdrawn in several markets for poor sales, I think the days are numbered for traditional car makers they have been slow to respond and not been good enough look the issues with the ID 3 quality wise. Kia/Hyundia have become much bigger players since they took BEV and hybrids seriously, plus they branched out into Europe to make them as well.

As said I have a BEV I like it, it suits my day to day needs but sometimes feel restricted and would like a range extender or hybrid with a real EV range but UK government policy will not allow this.

Simply put BEVs are not the perfect answer for everyone I don't think that is in dispute, but right now the UK gov are forcing this agenda with no options they are detached from the public.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top