Beer logo and pump scrapped after knife complaint

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Chippy_Tea

Landlord.
Staff member
Administrator
Moderator
Joined
Mar 17, 2013
Messages
54,876
Reaction score
21,625
Location
Ulverston Cumbria.
The world has gone mad -


A beer logo created in memory of a Sheffield cutlery legend has been discontinued after a member of the public complained that it encouraged violence.

The ale, named in honour of Stan Shaw, last of the "little mesters" knife makers, was served using a specially-made ornamental knife handle and tap clip at a bar in Sheffield.

1737463039977.png


1737463052639.png




A complaint about the pump and clip, which featured a cartoon of Mr Shaw holding a knife, was upheld by alcohol industry regulator The Portman Group.

Ben Shaw, director of the Little Mesters Brewing company which produced the beer, said he was "devastated" by the decision. The regulator said a drink should not suggest any association with violent behaviour.

Stan Shaw, who died at the age of 93 in 2021, made knives for The Queen, US presidents and Elvis Presley.

The beer was launched in 2022 to honour his skills and the company had received no other complaints about it in this time, according to a report by The Portman Group.

The complaint was handled by the independent complaints panel.

Rachel Childs, chair of the group, said the panel "acknowledged that the producer had simply sought to celebrate an important local craftsman".

However, she highlighted rising rates of knife crime in Sheffield, where the marketing had appeared, which had generated a high level of concern.

"It's important to remember that any depiction of knives on alcoholic packaging has to be approached with great caution," she said.

There was no blade or suggestion of a blade attached to the pump handle, the report said.

Mr Shaw, who is not related to Stan Shaw, said staff at the brewery were "absolutely devastated".

"We were so proud to be commemorating Stan's life and work, and all the little mesters.

"We completely innocently came up with a branding, which is relevant to Stan, and having to remove that or change it feels like a real kick."

Stan Shaw's son Kevan said he was "staggered" by the complaint.

He said he felt it was "ludicrous" to find a cartoon of his father holding a knife to be offensive and that the photo the cartoon was based on had been used "extensively" over the years.

A spokesperson for the brewery said no further products with the current logo would be made but existing stock would continue to be sold.

Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North or tell us a story you think we should be covering here, external.
 
The Portman Group are fairly toothless and many breweries seem to ignore them.

They're specifically there to regulate the naming, packaging, promotion, and sponsorship of alcoholic drinks; so despite this decision being a load of old bollocks the comparison with Wilkinson Sword does't quite hit the mark.

Recent investigations seem to be targetting Beak.

When I lived at the in-laws a Met Police Officer used to regularly make reports to them about beers sold in the Sainsbury's. Assume off-duty as the supermarket was in a Surrey Police area. Sad bastard.

Would be interesting if they went for Captain Morgan though, surely pirates/privateers would be an clear assocation with violence.
 
Last edited:
A ruling from the Portman group can totally **** you over if you sell to outlets that agree to abide by it's decisions, which includes all major supermarkets, and pub chains, as you have to change your packaging. It is therefore a wet dream for the neo-Puritans who can just keep making complaints in the hope they bankrupt yet another small producer. The big boys, who fund the group, find this most useful.
 
The Portman Group is funded by the following companies: Asahi UK; Aston Manor Cider; Bacardi; Brown-Forman Brands UK; Budweiser Brewing Group UK&I; Carlsberg UK; Diageo GB; Heineken UK; Mast-Jäegermeister UK; Pernod Ricard UK; SHS Drinks.

So consider whose interests they are protecting.
 
Back
Top