Sliding way off topic but hey...
...I absolutely agree! GW's recipes are really good, they do come up a fair bit like the brewery's beers but you're never going to make an exact replica. It's about knowing the beers you like and either brewing them to the recipe bearing in mind that it's going to be similar, not necessarily "the same", or using the recipes as a base for something you know is a style you'll like.
I think my AG#1 Hooky Bitter was bang on recipe and was pretty close to the result, the Kingsdown seems pretty close at this stage even though I had to substitute hops and screwed up the schedule and the FortyNiner was quite radically different because of the hop substitutions I made but there were still similarities to the real one.
I don't see the point in true replicas myself. So long as I get good tasty beer that comes out mostly like it was intended then that's where I want to be. :thumb: