Open Fermentation and/or Different Fermenter Geometry.

Advertise with us
shop deals on amazon
Shop deals on ebay
The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Its still interesting that there was difference at the batch size brewed, with a yeast that is sold on its consistency across brewing conditions. It certainly challanged my preconception it would be too neutral.

"Neutral flavor and consistent performance across diverse fermentation conditions make LalBrew Nottingham™ and ideal house strain for producing a wide variety of beer styles."
 
Sadfield said:
Its still interesting that there was difference at the batch size brewed, with a yeast that is sold on its consistency across brewing conditions. It certainly challanged my preconception it would be too neutral.

"Neutral flavor and consistent performance across diverse fermentation conditions make LalBrew Nottingham™ and ideal house strain for producing a wide variety of beer styles."
Click to expand...

Yes, when I read your post about yeast choice I thought "Whoops, I've messed this up" but there is an expression of difference.
 
20241112_194350.jpg


My Porter fermentation is well underway! The brew fridge smells of banana and chocolate, like those chocolate covered bananas you used to (still?) get in pick & mix.

No idea if that's a good thing but we'll find out on a few weeks! I suppose Hefeweizen yeasts produce banana aromas, and I'd guess the chocolate is coming from the dark malts 🤔
 
Not completely sure from the image, but I put my temp probe taped on above the heat belt. But on the area above the heat belt cable/ supply. Matches the ispindel well with this method.
 
Had this thread pointed out to me and must say it is a very fascinating read. What stunned me most was the discernable difference with Nottingham, I totally would have thought it would result in very similar beers.

I only ever once did a semi-open fermentation when brewing a NEIPA with London Ale III, because that one is said to need a particularly large amount of oxygen to fully attenuate. So on day 3 or 4 I took a paper fan and blew some air onto the krausen. I got quite a smooth fermentation and good precipitation, while later beers with the Verdant dry yeast and closed fermentation gave me more headaches.

It is definitely something I need to try out more often. But since I use a small room for fermentation since I don't have a fridge, it is a bit more risky.
 
Colindo said:
Had this thread pointed out to me and must say it is a very fascinating read. What stunned me most was the discernable difference with Nottingham, I totally would have thought it would result in very similar beers.

I only ever once did a semi-open fermentation when brewing a NEIPA with London Ale III, because that one is said to need a particularly large amount of oxygen to fully attenuate. So on day 3 or 4 I took a paper fan and blew some air onto the krausen. I got quite a smooth fermentation and good precipitation, while later beers with the Verdant dry yeast and closed fermentation gave me more headaches.

It is definitely something I need to try out more often. But since I use a small room for fermentation since I don't have a fridge, it is a bit more risky.
Click to expand...

My batches were in the brew fridge for temp control rather than any protection.

See pictures in first post.

Your small room would be fine. I can understand your nervousness, nasties in the air might infect it. I used to worry if my FV wasn’t perfectly sealed so the bubbler worked.

Do a small batch which you don’t have to worry about and leave it open.
 
Spicy World Tartaric Acid Pure 3.5oz - Top Grade, USP Certified, Food Grade, Vegan - Perfect for Wine Making, Mead
£14.38 (£144.93 / kg)
Spicy World Tartaric Acid Pure 3.5oz - Top Grade, USP Certified, Food Grade, Vegan - Perfect for Wine Making, Mead Amazon US
ALCOTEC Wine Yeast Universal 40g - AROMATIC WINE COMPLEX - Yeast + Nutrient + Enzymes - Home Brew Yeasts, Wine Making Yeast, Homebrew, Wine meter …
£5.25 (£131.25 / kg)
ALCOTEC Wine Yeast Universal 40g - AROMATIC WINE COMPLEX - Yeast + Nutrient + Enzymes - Home Brew Yeasts, Wine Making Yeast, Homebrew, Wine meter … do-it-at-home
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304(with Fittings)
£102.31
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304(with Fittings) zhaoweiamzqa
Brewing Mate 2 x Demijohn Airlock and Bung Set, Bubbler Air Lock for Home Brewing, Essential Equipment for Wine Making and Cider Making
-5%
£9.45 £9.99
Brewing Mate 2 x Demijohn Airlock and Bung Set, Bubbler Air Lock for Home Brewing, Essential Equipment for Wine Making and Cider Making Stratum One
Historical Brewing Techniques: The Lost Art of Farmhouse Brewing
-29%
£14.25 £19.99
Historical Brewing Techniques: The Lost Art of Farmhouse Brewing Amazon.co.uk
Premium 25 Litre Beer and Wine Making Starter Kit with 2 Buckets Makes 30 or 60 Bottles, Equipment Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment Almost Off Grid
£46.95
Premium 25 Litre Beer and Wine Making Starter Kit with 2 Buckets Makes 30 or 60 Bottles, Equipment Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment Almost Off Grid Almost Off Grid
Craft Brew: 50 homebrew recipes from the world's best craft breweries
-39%
£9.10 £14.99
Craft Brew: 50 homebrew recipes from the world's best craft breweries Pearly Books
Sanitary clamp 1.5" (38mm) OD50.5mm Sanitary Tri-Clamp 90-Degree Pipe With Nipple And Electronic Thermometer, Stainless Steel 304 Home brewing(Without Thermometer)
£63.25
Sanitary clamp 1.5" (38mm) OD50.5mm Sanitary Tri-Clamp 90-Degree Pipe With Nipple And Electronic Thermometer, Stainless Steel 304 Home brewing(Without Thermometer) DAN CHENG XIAN PENG SHI DA SHANG MAO DIAN
Digital Temperature Watch Heating Thermometer Home Brewing Tools for Wine Bottle
£14.76
Digital Temperature Watch Heating Thermometer Home Brewing Tools for Wine Bottle B&D DIRECT STORE
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing Distillation,SS304 ICXLPMC(Main Body)
£56.45
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing Distillation,SS304 ICXLPMC(Main Body) chengshifengamz
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 HMCOCOOFM(with Fittings)
£103.05
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 HMCOCOOFM(with Fittings) weifangguanhuawangluokejiyouxiangongsi
BALLIIHOO Homebrew Kit - Basic Starter Equipment Set with 40 Pint Cider Ingredients & 1Kg Brewing Sugar
£52.31
BALLIIHOO Homebrew Kit - Basic Starter Equipment Set with 40 Pint Cider Ingredients & 1Kg Brewing Sugar BalliihooHomebrew
Finlandia Cider - 40 Pint Homebrew Ingredient Kit Including 1Kg Vinclasse Brewing Sugar
£23.35
Finlandia Cider - 40 Pint Homebrew Ingredient Kit Including 1Kg Vinclasse Brewing Sugar BalliihooHomebrew
How to Brew: Everything You Need to Know to Brew Great Beer Every Time
-25%
£14.25 £18.99
How to Brew: Everything You Need to Know to Brew Great Beer Every Time Amazon.co.uk
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer Making Kit 5 litre George's Beer Home Brew Craft Beer Starter Kit Equipment and Ingredients (PILS)
£35.95
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer Making Kit 5 litre George's Beer Home Brew Craft Beer Starter Kit Equipment and Ingredients (PILS) do-it-at-home
2x Mangrove Jack’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g)
-8%
£6.89 (£344.50 / kg) £7.51 (£375.50 / kg)
2x Mangrove Jack’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g) do-it-at-home
Mangrove Jack 3X ’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g)
-12%
£10.49 (£349.67 / kg) £11.96 (£398.67 / kg)
Mangrove Jack 3X ’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g) Almost Off Grid
The Brew Your Own Big Book of Clone Recipes: Featuring 300 Homebrew Recipes from Your Favorite Breweries
-6%
£15.96 £16.99
The Brew Your Own Big Book of Clone Recipes: Featuring 300 Homebrew Recipes from Your Favorite Breweries Amazon.co.uk
Wild Brews: The craft of home brewing, from sour and fruit beers to farmhouse ales: WINNER OF THE FORTNUM & MASON DEBUT DRINK BOOK AWARD
-20%
£17.66 £22.00
Wild Brews: The craft of home brewing, from sour and fruit beers to farmhouse ales: WINNER OF THE FORTNUM & MASON DEBUT DRINK BOOK AWARD Amazon.co.uk
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 ZUZAOJUYIN(with Fittings)
£104.00
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 ZUZAOJUYIN(with Fittings) zhuzhaojunamz
The Modern Homebrewer
-22%
£14.85 £18.99
The Modern Homebrewer Amazon.co.uk
Almost Off Grid 25 Litre Home Brewing Kit for Beginners, Makes 30 Bottles, Equipment Starter Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment
-6%
£29.95 £31.95
Almost Off Grid 25 Litre Home Brewing Kit for Beginners, Makes 30 Bottles, Equipment Starter Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment Almost Off Grid
NHKSFBLQ 2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer With (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector For Homebrewing,SS304(With Fittings)
£101.58
NHKSFBLQ 2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer With (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector For Homebrewing,SS304(With Fittings) zhaojingouz
Brewing Classic Styles: 80 Winning Recipes Anyone Can Brew
-21%
£11.85 £14.99
Brewing Classic Styles: 80 Winning Recipes Anyone Can Brew Amazon.co.uk
BJ #3 Kit - Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (6 Bottles Size)
£44.99
BJ #3 Kit - Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (6 Bottles Size) BiggerJugs
Lalvin EC-1118 Wine Yeast (10 Pack) - Champagne Yeast - Make Wine Cider Mead Kombucha At Home - 5 g Sachets - Saccharomyces cerevisiae - Sold by CAPYBARA Distributors Inc.
£9.99 (£199.80 / kg)
Lalvin EC-1118 Wine Yeast (10 Pack) - Champagne Yeast - Make Wine Cider Mead Kombucha At Home - 5 g Sachets - Saccharomyces cerevisiae - Sold by CAPYBARA Distributors Inc. CAPYBARA Distributors Inc. (UK)
Almost Off Grid Mead Yeast - 10g Sachet
£3.99 (£399.00 / kg)
Almost Off Grid Mead Yeast - 10g Sachet Almost Off Grid
Shepherd Made Mead Making Kit (Mead-Kit), Multicolored
£30.68
Shepherd Made Mead Making Kit (Mead-Kit), Multicolored Amazon US
The Meaning of Beer: The Surprising Story of how Beer Made Us
-19%
£13.69 £16.99
The Meaning of Beer: The Surprising Story of how Beer Made Us Amazon.co.uk
BJ #5s Kit - 25L Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (30 Bottles Size)
£45.99
BJ #5s Kit - 25L Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (30 Bottles Size) BiggerJugs
2X Bulldog Mead Yeast & Nutrient High Alcohol 28g for 20-25L
£6.59 (£235.36 / kg)
2X Bulldog Mead Yeast & Nutrient High Alcohol 28g for 20-25L do-it-at-home
BAWHO 4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head For Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm QINTINYIN(With Thermometer)
£445.68
BAWHO 4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head For Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm QINTINYIN(With Thermometer) hnhktrsmyxgs
Brew it Yourself: Make Your Own Beer, Wine, Cider and Other Concoctions
-27%
£10.99 £14.99
Brew it Yourself: Make Your Own Beer, Wine, Cider and Other Concoctions ST Bookstores
BALLIIHOO 30 Litre Homebrew and Winemaking Fermentation Bucket with Lever Tap & LCD Temperature Strip
£20.89
BALLIIHOO 30 Litre Homebrew and Winemaking Fermentation Bucket with Lever Tap & LCD Temperature Strip BalliihooHomebrew
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 UGLJUNDU(with Fittings)
£102.31
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 UGLJUNDU(with Fittings) chuyitongamz
4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head for Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm(with Thermometer)
£450.65
4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head for Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm(with Thermometer) nixuouz
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer & Wine Making Starter Kit - Basic Equipment - All You Need in One Box Homemade Beer & Wine Home Brewing
£32.95
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer & Wine Making Starter Kit - Basic Equipment - All You Need in One Box Homemade Beer & Wine Home Brewing do-it-at-home
Bulldog Brews Mead Yeast and Nutrient
£4.49 (£0.18 / l)
Bulldog Brews Mead Yeast and Nutrient BalliihooHomebrew
Wye Valley Meadery Traditional Mead (70cl Bottle), 14.5% ABV
£29.95 (£32.09 / 75 cl)
Wye Valley Meadery Traditional Mead (70cl Bottle), 14.5% ABV Saxtys Wines
FOR THE LOVE OF HOPS (Brewing Elements): The Practical Guide to Aroma, Bitterness and the Culture of Hops
-20%
£11.95 £14.99
FOR THE LOVE OF HOPS (Brewing Elements): The Practical Guide to Aroma, Bitterness and the Culture of Hops Amazon.co.uk
It'll be fine as long as there's krausen formed, covering the beer and active fermentation releasing CO2. And, no pets or kids diving into it.
 
matt76 said:
View attachment 105680

My Porter fermentation is well underway! The brew fridge smells of banana and chocolate, like those chocolate covered bananas you used to (still?) get in pick & mix.

No idea if that's a good thing but we'll find out on a few weeks! I suppose Hefeweizen yeasts produce banana aromas, and I'd guess the chocolate is coming from the dark malts 🤔
Click to expand...
I kegged my Porter the other day. I'll give it until next weekend before I tap the keg - I find these dark beers tend to mellow and the flavours round off more after a bit more time, but I'm an impatient so and so.

No closed control fermentation to compare it against, but the hydrometer sample tasted good.

I'm fementing something pale and hoppy closed at the moment but once that's done I fancy doing another bitter - I think I'm gonna try culturing up some Fuller's yeast from a couple of bottles of 1845 and then ferment it open.
 
Northern_Brewer said:
Get it while you can, Lancer has just been discontinued. Don't know if that also applies to the Fuller's IPA which was essentially the same beer for export markets.
Click to expand...
Wow, that is crazy. India Pale Ale is one of the most imported British beers in continental Europe. Easier to get than London Porter by far.

Edit: Any idea how Griffin IPA compares to Bengal Lancer? Just spotted it on their website.
 
Last edited:
Colindo said:
Wow, that is crazy. India Pale Ale is one of the most imported British beers in continental Europe. Easier to get than London Porter by far.

Edit: Any idea how Griffin IPA compares to Bengal Lancer? Just spotted it on their website.
Click to expand...
I've not had it, but it looks like it was a "one-off" that is intended to replace Lancer in the long run - slight tweak to the hops (adding Fuggles to the Goldings) and a more neutral name that matches the new Griffin Gold, but still bottle conditioned.
 
I am currently fermenting as openly as I dare by just gently leaving the lid on. The yeast is loving it so far, I'll see if I can take a picture later. I bought W-100 from the Weihenstephan yeast bank which is one of their four British strains and it definitely gives a strong British barm that I can imagine benefits from keeping it open.
 
London Pride clone brewed and now fermenting open in the brew fridge. In the pic below this is just foam on the surface from aeration when I drained the kettle to the FV but hoping to see a healthy krausen soon. I'll ferment open and feeling like I want to have another try at transferring to a keg with spunding valve to carbonate naturally, but haven't decided 100% on this yet.

20241211_110420.jpg
 

Latest posts

Back
Top