I had written a reply but it wasn't fair on you Ben to include lots of competitors names in the reply here. I do think it's a really competitive space, and much will depend on the audience. I don't have any evidence but my suspicion is that the majority of home brewers and largest spend is on kits, either extract or grain. Haute couture all grain is where a fair few on the forum here aim for but that is I suspect a fairly rarified audience. For me it's about being a site that can be authoritative and give confidence in a particular area of homebrewing. So for me at the moment, I have a range of sites that I have confidence in the range or quality of their products/service, or that their products are unique. But that also means I go to different places for different needs and I'm probably not the target audience. It does make me wonder if any home brew sites are providing reviews of kits so can make a recommendation, or have an active customer feedback review system on kits, sharing subjective experiences. As a bit of feedback, labelling all beer and wine kits as 'starter kits' in the navigation does also feel a bit patronising.
So yes, I do fairly regularly take a look at your site, and your prices are good, and I like the hops you have. It doesn't provide all the information I'm looking for on the hops/grain to make me feel confident in ordering at the moment but as above, I'm not entirely sure I'm the right spending audience.
Anna