the inside 1 looks fine but the outer 1 looks a little like its misshaped but maybe its just me , mine fit snug yours looks a little loose , not totally fitted all the way up in a near perfect line , maybe it was just because the water inside was a little too hot when you cleaned it causing air expansion and all is fine after all , however you can buy new rubbers for about 40p i got some in my local home brew shop maybe best to change the outer 1