Bottling experiment ... priming rates

The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Baz Chaz

Landlord.
Joined
Aug 15, 2010
Messages
1,937
Reaction score
144
There seems to have been a few questions recently about priming brews, batch priming or bottle priming, well I'm a batch primer personally, so I thought I'd do a bit of an experiment ....... no not another along the line of my 'bottle bomb' experiment, more of a how little could you prime per bottle :idea:

I don't like fizzy beer, which is my personal preference, so I'm happy to be priming on the low side, like I said, I batch prime so while bottling this morning I made 20 ltrs available for experimentation purposes, 20 ltrs make for easy maths :geek:

Normally batch at 80g for 23 ltr (but have been down to 60g) and I only use plain old granulated sugar, nothing fancy, so a rough average of 3.5g per litre. 3.5g x 23ltr = 80.5g would be my norm.

A heaped teaspoon (I mean heaped, as much as you can get on one) I weighed out at 8g, a level teaspoon (scraped flat with a knife)weighed out at 3g, so my normal batch primed bottles would have the equivalent of half a level teaspoon if bottle primed, thats not a big amount when you see it after you've weighed it.

Today I did 40 bottles in 4 batches of 10 at 1g per ltr 2g per ltr 3g per ltr & 4g per ltr

First 5 litres (10 bottles) had 5g sugar in 100 ml solution in then bottled ...
2nd 5 ltr had 10g - 3rd had 15g and 4th 20g.

I don't think you could do the smaller amounts of sugar other than by batch priming !

Now then, I know there are so many variables between brews, but by doing it this way, hopefull should be able to get a reasonable comparison between each batch of 10, they're all now in a warm spot for a week before going to storage.

The brew was Jennings Cumberland Ale recipe from the GW book ABV 4.1% ...... so now the wait begins.

I'll leave 'em a few weeks then will start having a test, just realised, will have to drink one of each batch to make sure its a fair test :whistle: I reckon if more people got involved in experimentation like this science etc would become much more supported / interesting :cheers:

For anyone interested in priming at much higher rates see ....

Bottle Bombs
 
I have found that 1/2tsp of sugar / bottle works for me. Not overly carbonated but gives a satisfying hiss when you remove the bottle top.
 
These bottles are now being opened and drunk :cheers:

I've tried one of the one and a half grams per 500ml bottle and one of the two grams per 500ml.

These were bottled early October, spent a week in the warm then out to 'The Den' .


To be honest, I found there was very little difference between the two, but both were a bit fizzier than I like, a decent head, not overflowing or anything, but just a bit too much.

Hopefully the half and the one gram per 500ml bottles will be more to my preference.
 
Cheers Baz...I've never done an experiment on these lines and your result of one and a half grams of sugar per 500ml bottle has surprised me.
I always work on 3 gms per bottle and its been fine for me.
Of course the result we all use will depend on our own individual tastes...but none the less I'm surprised at the result.
 
piddledribble said:
Cheers Baz...I've never done an experiment on these lines and your result of one and a half grams of sugar per 500ml bottle has surprised me..

Have you had a read through the other 'experiment' I did, this was even 'heavier' on the old granular additions ............

Bottle Bombs
 
yep read that one when first posted, and I did wear a tin hat.
 
Baz Chaz said:
....... Hopefully the half and the one gram per 500ml bottles will be more to my preference.


Well last night I had one of each of the half and one gram bottles and there was a difference, there was the 'smoking gun' on opening and only a little 'psssst'. Poured and there was some carbonation not as much as the previous 2 bottles, decent head and much better, to my non fizzy preference.

So will be sticking to my batch priming of no more than 60g per 23 ltr and am looking to go even lower, towards 40g I think :hmm:
 
Back
Top