Open Fermentation and/or Different Fermenter Geometry.

Advertise with us
Shop deals on ebay
shop deals on amazon
The Homebrew Forum

Help Support The Homebrew Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Found this thread fascinating.
However I’m now even more confused than normal. I have been going through a one person argument for several months as to whether to buy an overpriced shinny fermenter with full glycol chilling setup allowing closed transfer etc. As everyone knows, slightest hint of oxygen after the first few days of fermentation and beer might as well end up down the drain.
Not worried for my top fermenting ales but rather more concerned for lagers which will sit in the fermentation fridge for weeks (or months).
Reading the above, should I save my money and stick with my plastic bucket approach?

Also… if pressure kills yeast, how does pressure fermentation work?
 
DuncR said:
Also… if pressure kills yeast, how does pressure fermentation work?
Click to expand...
Pressure doesn't kill yeast.

Pressure increases CO2 in solution. CO2 in solution changes the way yeast function. Manly, it limits growth and therefore ester production.

"Our yeast contributes to 50% of the final flavour of our beer, which highlights how important it is that we keep our unique strain"

Above is a quote from Harvey's Brewery website, highlighting why one might not want to inhibit ester formation.

There's more information on pressure and esters in this piece.

https://wildflowerbeer.com/blogs/blog/process-e1-primary-fermentation-geometry
 
We have fermentation. I was initially concerned that the temperature of the wort in the gastronorm (love that word) wasn't climbing as fast as the pot then I realised that it has a greater surface area and no insulation (until it has a good krausen) so heat can escape easily. This might be a factor affecting the flavour profile as it will ferment cooler.

I'm thinking ahead to the transfer to the secondary. Technically the closed pot doesn't need it but as it could be a flavour affecting activity I'm going to do it anyway. Probably either later on on Sunday or Monday.
 
Open fermenter has taken off properly now (blue line) :-

Open.jpg


IMG_7647.jpg
 
Decanted them both as they had finished according to temperature profile and the fact that krausen had gone on most (forgot to take a picture aheadbutt ). Upped the temperature to 18.5 to encourage D-rest.

Immediate difference was that the open fermenter's beer was a LOT clearer, maybe because there was a greater area for the crud to settle out ?

Tasted and took a gravity from the closed fermenter (I didn't do a good job of syphoning and ended up with about a litre left so there was plenty to go at). Gravity was 1.009 and the taste was very nice.

One thing that surprised me was the fermentation temperature profiles were exactly the same time wise even though the closed one was 'hotter'. I was thinking that the closed one would have more heat in it therefore it would go faster but it wasn't the case. Nowhere near that point yet but there must be a taste difference between them from the heat dissipation.

Temperature charts...

Open2.jpg
 
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Fermenter 30l Fermentation Bucket with Tap, Airlock, Lid, and Bung, Homebrew Wine Making
£17.95
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Fermenter 30l Fermentation Bucket with Tap, Airlock, Lid, and Bung, Homebrew Wine Making do-it-at-home
2x Mangrove Jack’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g)
-8%
£6.89 (£344.50 / kg) £7.51 (£375.50 / kg)
2x Mangrove Jack’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g) do-it-at-home
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 UGLJUNDU(with Fittings)
£102.31
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 UGLJUNDU(with Fittings) chuyitongamz
BJ #5s Kit - 25L Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (30 Bottles Size)
£45.99
BJ #5s Kit - 25L Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (30 Bottles Size) BiggerJugs
Malt (Brewing Elements): A Practical Guide from Field to Brewhouse
-20%
£11.95 £14.99
Malt (Brewing Elements): A Practical Guide from Field to Brewhouse Amazon.co.uk
Wild Brews: The craft of home brewing, from sour and fruit beers to farmhouse ales: WINNER OF THE FORTNUM & MASON DEBUT DRINK BOOK AWARD
-25%
£16.57 £22.00
Wild Brews: The craft of home brewing, from sour and fruit beers to farmhouse ales: WINNER OF THE FORTNUM & MASON DEBUT DRINK BOOK AWARD Amazon.co.uk
Digital Temperature Watch Heating Thermometer Home Brewing Tools for Wine Bottle
£14.76
Digital Temperature Watch Heating Thermometer Home Brewing Tools for Wine Bottle B&D DIRECT STORE
BJ #3 Kit - Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (6 Bottles Size)
£44.99
BJ #3 Kit - Premium Winemaking Equipment Set (6 Bottles Size) BiggerJugs
Brew it Yourself: Make Your Own Beer, Wine, Cider and Other Concoctions
-27%
£10.99 £14.99
Brew it Yourself: Make Your Own Beer, Wine, Cider and Other Concoctions ST Bookstores
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing Distillation,SS304 ICXLPMC(Main Body)
£56.45
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing Distillation,SS304 ICXLPMC(Main Body) chengshifengamz
5 x Honey Yeast Bulldog Mead
£10.99 (£2.20 / count)
5 x Honey Yeast Bulldog Mead do-it-at-home
Home Brew Hydrometer with Included 100 Millimeter Trial Sampling Jar - Home Brew Equipment for Wine and Beer Making Testing Kit and Brewing Your Own Homebrew
£9.95
Home Brew Hydrometer with Included 100 Millimeter Trial Sampling Jar - Home Brew Equipment for Wine and Beer Making Testing Kit and Brewing Your Own Homebrew Thermometer World
Lalvin EC-1118 Wine Yeast (10 Pack) - Champagne Yeast - Make Wine Cider Mead Kombucha At Home - 5 g Sachets - Saccharomyces cerevisiae - Sold by CAPYBARA Distributors Inc.
£9.99 (£199.80 / kg)
Lalvin EC-1118 Wine Yeast (10 Pack) - Champagne Yeast - Make Wine Cider Mead Kombucha At Home - 5 g Sachets - Saccharomyces cerevisiae - Sold by CAPYBARA Distributors Inc. CAPYBARA Distributors Inc. (UK)
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304(with Fittings)
£102.31
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304(with Fittings) zhaoweiamzqa
BALLIIHOO 30 Litre Homebrew and Winemaking Fermentation Bucket with Lever Tap & LCD Temperature Strip
£23.20
BALLIIHOO 30 Litre Homebrew and Winemaking Fermentation Bucket with Lever Tap & LCD Temperature Strip BalliihooHomebrew
2X Bulldog Mead Yeast & Nutrient High Alcohol 28g for 20-25L
£6.59 (£235.36 / kg)
2X Bulldog Mead Yeast & Nutrient High Alcohol 28g for 20-25L do-it-at-home
The Modern Homebrewer
-22%
£14.85 £18.99
The Modern Homebrewer Amazon.co.uk
Bulldog Brews Mead Yeast and Nutrient
£5.06 (£0.20 / l)
Bulldog Brews Mead Yeast and Nutrient do-it-at-home
Sanitary clamp 1.5" (38mm) OD50.5mm Sanitary Tri-Clamp 90-Degree Pipe With Nipple And Electronic Thermometer, Stainless Steel 304 Home brewing(Without Thermometer)
£63.25
Sanitary clamp 1.5" (38mm) OD50.5mm Sanitary Tri-Clamp 90-Degree Pipe With Nipple And Electronic Thermometer, Stainless Steel 304 Home brewing(Without Thermometer) DAN CHENG XIAN PENG SHI DA SHANG MAO DIAN
NHKSFBLQ 2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer With (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector For Homebrewing,SS304(With Fittings)
£101.58
NHKSFBLQ 2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer With (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector For Homebrewing,SS304(With Fittings) zhaojingouz
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 HMCOCOOFM(with Fittings)
£103.05
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 HMCOCOOFM(with Fittings) weifangguanhuawangluokejiyouxiangongsi
Premium 25 Litre Beer and Wine Making Starter Kit with 2 Buckets Makes 30 or 60 Bottles, Equipment Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment Almost Off Grid
£46.95
Premium 25 Litre Beer and Wine Making Starter Kit with 2 Buckets Makes 30 or 60 Bottles, Equipment Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment Almost Off Grid Almost Off Grid
Mangrove Jack 10x Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g)
-10%
£23.05 (£230.50 / kg) £25.60 (£256.00 / kg)
Mangrove Jack 10x Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g) 247 Homebrew
Mangrove Jack 3X ’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g)
-12%
£10.49 (£349.67 / kg) £11.96 (£398.67 / kg)
Mangrove Jack 3X ’s Craft Series Mead Yeast M05 (10g) Almost Off Grid
FOR THE LOVE OF HOPS (Brewing Elements): The Practical Guide to Aroma, Bitterness and the Culture of Hops
-20%
£11.95 £14.99
FOR THE LOVE OF HOPS (Brewing Elements): The Practical Guide to Aroma, Bitterness and the Culture of Hops Amazon.co.uk
How to Brew: Everything You Need to Know to Brew Great Beer Every Time
-25%
£14.25 £18.99
How to Brew: Everything You Need to Know to Brew Great Beer Every Time Amazon.co.uk
Brewing Classic Styles: 80 Winning Recipes Anyone Can Brew
-21%
£11.85 £14.99
Brewing Classic Styles: 80 Winning Recipes Anyone Can Brew Amazon.co.uk
BALLIIHOO Homebrew Kit - Basic Starter Equipment Set with 40 Pint Cider Ingredients & 1Kg Brewing Sugar
£57.76
BALLIIHOO Homebrew Kit - Basic Starter Equipment Set with 40 Pint Cider Ingredients & 1Kg Brewing Sugar BalliihooHomebrew
Historical Brewing Techniques: The Lost Art of Farmhouse Brewing
-29%
£14.25 £19.99
Historical Brewing Techniques: The Lost Art of Farmhouse Brewing Amazon.co.uk
BAWHO 4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head For Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm QINTINYIN(With Thermometer)
£445.68
BAWHO 4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head For Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm QINTINYIN(With Thermometer) hnhktrsmyxgs
Wye Valley Meadery Traditional Mead (70cl Bottle), 14.5% ABV
£29.95 (£32.09 / 75 cl)
Wye Valley Meadery Traditional Mead (70cl Bottle), 14.5% ABV Saxtys Wines
Almost Off Grid 25 Litre Home Brewing Kit for Beginners, Makes 30 Bottles, Equipment Starter Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment
-6%
£29.95 £31.95
Almost Off Grid 25 Litre Home Brewing Kit for Beginners, Makes 30 Bottles, Equipment Starter Kit, Homebrewing Set for Wine, Beer, Cider and Mead Making, Basic Brewing Equipment Almost Off Grid
ALCOTEC Wine Yeast Universal 40g - AROMATIC WINE COMPLEX - Yeast + Nutrient + Enzymes - Home Brew Yeasts, Wine Making Yeast, Homebrew, Wine meter …
£5.25 (£131.25 / kg)
ALCOTEC Wine Yeast Universal 40g - AROMATIC WINE COMPLEX - Yeast + Nutrient + Enzymes - Home Brew Yeasts, Wine Making Yeast, Homebrew, Wine meter … do-it-at-home
The Meaning of Beer: The Surprising Story of how Beer Made Us
-19%
£13.69 £16.99
The Meaning of Beer: The Surprising Story of how Beer Made Us Amazon.co.uk
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer & Wine Making Starter Kit - Basic Equipment - All You Need in One Box Homemade Beer & Wine Home Brewing
£32.95
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer & Wine Making Starter Kit - Basic Equipment - All You Need in One Box Homemade Beer & Wine Home Brewing do-it-at-home
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer Making Kit 5 litre George's Beer Home Brew Craft Beer Starter Kit Equipment and Ingredients (PILS)
£35.95
DIAH DO IT AT HOME Beer Making Kit 5 litre George's Beer Home Brew Craft Beer Starter Kit Equipment and Ingredients (PILS) do-it-at-home
Brewing
-8%
£25.75 £27.99
Brewing Amazon.co.uk
Almost Off Grid Mead Yeast - 10g Sachet
£3.99 (£399.00 / kg)
Almost Off Grid Mead Yeast - 10g Sachet Almost Off Grid
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 ZUZAOJUYIN(with Fittings)
£104.00
2" OD64mm x 1.5" OD50.5mm Tri- Clamp Reducer with (19mm) OD50.5mm Thermometer Connector for Homebrewing,SS304 ZUZAOJUYIN(with Fittings) zhuzhaojunamz
4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head for Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm(with Thermometer)
£450.65
4L 4" OD119mm * 1.5" OD50.5mm Copper Onion Head for Homebrewing,Thickness 1.5mm(with Thermometer) nixuouz
I don't really want to coment too much on this, so as not to influence your tasting, but it is very interesting. I no longer use temperature control, and don't miss it.
 
Sadfield said:
I don't really want to coment too much on this, so as not to influence your tasting, but it is very interesting. I no longer use temperature control, and don't miss it.
Click to expand...

Can’t wait to taste. At some point you need to pm me with your address as you are on the tasting panel. They will be supplied as sample A and B.
 
I doubt the open ferment would have been any clearer if you had taken a sample to check clarity from the top of the closed ferment.
Yeast floccs out via gravity, temp profile difference could also be related to the fact the closed ferment was higher in your ferment chamber. Plus sitting above the open ferment which generates heat.
Standing by for differences.
 
RoomWithABrew said:
I doubt the open ferment would have been any clearer if you had taken a sample to check clarity from the top of the closed ferment.
Yeast floccs out via gravity, temp profile difference could also be related to the fact the closed ferment was higher in your ferment chamber. Plus sitting above the open ferment which generates heat.
Standing by for differences.
Click to expand...

Doubt away but it was clearer, a lot, like the difference between an IPA and a hazy IPA. Made me wonder if there was something wrong with the closed one. I'll see if I can get a photo later.

The closed ferment was below not above. See picture from Saturday morning above, the open ferment it at the top.
 
RoomWithABrew said:
my apologies re the positioning. I'm in NZ so must have been an upside down memory!

Cooler beer will encourage the drop of yeast a bit quicker though.
Click to expand...

No worries 😂.

It’s an interesting project, a lot riding on the taste test. If it turns out nice I might get a bigger gastronorm. I like the way it slides into the fridge shelf slots.
 
Twostage said:
No worries 😂.

It’s an interesting project, a lot riding on the taste test. If it turns out nice I might get a bigger gastronorm. I like the way it slides into the fridge shelf slots.
Click to expand...
Out of interest, what's the width of your fridge and the gastronorm? Wondering if it would work in mine... 🤔
 
Stainless steel sinks come in many sizes and might work, they have a handy hole in the bottom that could be used with butterfly valve to drop / harvest yeast.
We might be creating an environment with a much greater surface to volume ratio than the famous open fermenters used commercially.
But I'm not exactly sure of the dimensions of say the Harveys fermenters.
 
Not sure how the statement " fermenters have a shallower height to diameter ratio, which is 1:1. "

Would think this means that the height is equal to the diameter, ie 1 foot deep has a 1x1 surface. But the statement isn't clear to me.
 
RoomWithABrew said:
" fermenters have a shallower height to diameter ratio, which is 1:1. "
Click to expand...

Square ones won't. 😉

The ones at Harvey's look to be about 1.5m deep and Φ3m. Brasserie Dupont have a wort depth of 1m. Anything with a wort height lower than the vessel width, the lower the less pressure. As can be seen in this Sierra Neveda clip, some aren't very deep. Approximately, a 1:5 height to diameter ratio, if you adjust from square to round.

 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top